Migrating from Jenkins to TeamCity: Step-by-Step PlanMigrating your CI/CD platform from Jenkins to TeamCity can deliver faster builds, clearer UI, tighter security defaults, and better out-of-the-box support for distributed builds. This guide provides a practical, step-by-step plan to migrate with minimal disruption, maintain developer productivity, and avoid common pitfalls.
1. Plan and prepare
- Inventory current Jenkins setup:
- Catalog jobs (freestyle, pipeline, multibranch), their triggers, schedules, and dependency graphs.
- List plugins in use and their purpose (credentials storage, code analysis, notifications, artifact publishing, SCM integrations, container tooling, etc.).
- Record secrets, credentials, and their scopes (be cautious: handle credentials securely).
- Note build agents (capacity, OS, custom tools), resource-heavy jobs, and long-running tasks.
- Define migration goals:
- Which jobs move first (low-risk vs. high-value)?
- Expected downtime windows and rollback criteria.
- Desired TeamCity features to adopt (build chains, templates, Kotlin DSL, integrated VCS triggers, parallelism).
- Stakeholders and communication:
- Assign owners for migration, validation, and rollback.
- Communicate timeline and testing periods with teams.
- Prepare test environment:
- Stand up a TeamCity server (trial or appropriate license), and at least one agent mirroring your production runner environment.
- Configure backups for Jenkins data and TeamCity configuration snapshots.
2. Evaluate plugins and features mapping
- Map Jenkins plugins to TeamCity equivalents:
- Many Jenkins plugins have direct equivalents or are unnecessary in TeamCity due to built-in features (e.g., artifact handling, build chains, parameterized builds).
- For specialized plugins, explore TeamCity plugins marketplace or implement the functionality using custom scripts in build steps.
- Identify missing features:
- If a Jenkins plugin has no TeamCity counterpart, decide whether to:
- Implement a scriptable workaround,
- Build a custom TeamCity plugin,
- Keep that job in Jenkins until replacement is ready.
- If a Jenkins plugin has no TeamCity counterpart, decide whether to:
- Decide on secrets handling:
- TeamCity has its own secure variables and external integrations (e.g., HashiCorp Vault). Plan migration of credentials and service accounts.
3. Choose migration approach
- Big-bang migration:
- Move all pipelines at once.
- Pros: single supervised transition.
- Cons: higher risk, more coordination required.
- Phased migration (recommended):
- Migrate in waves: sandbox/utility jobs → low-risk builds → critical pipelines.
- Pros: lower risk, easier rollback, incremental learning.
- Hybrid approach:
- Keep some builds in Jenkins long-term for non-critical or plugin-dependent jobs.
4. Set up TeamCity server and agents
- Install TeamCity:
- Choose OS, database (internal H2 for trials; external DB — PostgreSQL, MySQL, or MS SQL — for production), and proper storage for artifacts and logs.
- Configure authentication:
- Integrate with your identity provider (LDAP, SAML, OAuth) or use built-in users for initial testing.
- Install and configure build agents:
- Create agent pools and assign capabilities (tools, SDKs).
- Mirror Jenkins agent images (Java, Docker, Node, Python, .NET SDKs) so builds run consistently.
- Configure server-level settings:
- Default VCS roots, artifact storage paths, global environment variables, and resource limits.
5. Recreate build configuration structure
- Use TeamCity Projects and Build Configurations:
- Map Jenkins folders/pipelines to TeamCity projects and subprojects.
- Prefer smaller, single-responsibility build configurations that can be chained.
- Adopt build templates:
- Extract common steps into templates (checkout, build, test, publish).
- Use parameters for environment-specific differences.
- Consider Kotlin DSL:
- For reproducible, code-driven configuration, use TeamCity Kotlin DSL stored in VCS.
- Advantages: reviewable changes, versioning, templating, and easier bulk edits.
- Translate pipelines:
- For Jenkins scripted/Declarative Pipelines, convert stages to TeamCity build steps or composite build chains. Steps can be shell, PowerShell, Docker, or runner-specific (Maven, Gradle, MSBuild).
- For multibranch pipelines, use TeamCity Branch Specifications and feature branches support.
6. Migrate SCM integrations and triggers
- Recreate VCS Roots and mappings:
- Point TeamCity to your Git/Perforce/SVN repos. Use the same authentication (deploy keys, service accounts) but migrate secrets securely.
- Configure branch handling:
- Define branch filters and default branch behavior.
- Enable automatic branch builds for feature branches if needed.
- Set up triggers:
- VCS triggers, schedule triggers, or custom webhooks.
- If you used GitHub/GitLab webhooks to trigger Jenkins, set webhooks to TeamCity’s VCS trigger or maintain a proxy that forwards events.
- Preserve commit-status reporting:
- Configure build status notifications back to Git hosting (GitHub Checks, GitLab statuses, Bitbucket). TeamCity supports these integrations.
7. Migrate artifacts and dependencies
- Artifact publishing:
- Map Jenkins artifact locations to TeamCity artifact paths.
- Configure artifact dependencies (snapshot/artifact dependencies) for build chains.
- Binary repositories:
- Continue using Nexus/Artifactory or configure TeamCity to publish artifacts to your artifact repository.
- Clean up retention policies:
- Define retention rules in TeamCity to control disk usage and artifact lifetime.
8. Migrate credentials and secrets
- Inventory secrets used in Jenkins (credentials plugin, environment variables, encrypted files).
- Import secrets into TeamCity:
- Use TeamCity secure parameters or integrate with external secret manager (HashiCorp Vault, AWS Secrets Manager).
- Validate permissions and access:
- Ensure service accounts, tokens, and SSH keys have least privilege.
9. Validate build correctness
- Run builds in parallel:
- Execute migrated builds in TeamCity while keeping Jenkins builds running (dual-run) for comparison.
- Start with non-critical and then increasingly important builds.
- Compare outputs:
- Verify artifacts, test results, timings, and environment parity.
- Check logs for environment differences (paths, tool versions).
- Performance testing:
- Run load tests on TeamCity agents to ensure capacity and scalability.
- Fix discrepancies:
- Adjust agent capabilities, environment variables, or build steps.
10. Cutover and decommission
- Final cutover checklist:
- Freeze changes on Jenkins jobs being migrated (short maintenance window) or coordinate final sync.
- Update developers and automation to use new TeamCity build URLs, statuses, and badges.
- Switch webhooks and repository integrations to point exclusively to TeamCity.
- Monitor closely after cutover:
- Watch for failed builds, missing artifacts, and permission issues.
- Decommission Jenkins:
- Keep Jenkins read-only for an archive period.
- Export job configs and build logs for compliance if required.
- Once confident, retire Jenkins hosts and reclaim infrastructure.
11. Post-migration improvements
- Embrace TeamCity features:
- Use build chain visualizations, parallel test splitting, and Kotlin DSL for maintainability.
- Clean and optimize:
- Consolidate duplicate steps into templates, remove unused projects and agents, and tune retention rules.
- Continuous improvement:
- Gather developer feedback and iterate on build speed, flakiness reduction, and test coverage.
- Documentation and training:
- Update runbooks, onboarding docs, and run short workshops for teams.
12. Common pitfalls and how to avoid them
- Underestimating plugin differences:
- Mitigation: inventory plugins early and prototype replacements.
- Not matching agent environments:
- Mitigation: reproduce toolchains in TeamCity agents or use containerized agents.
- Secrets migration mishaps:
- Mitigation: rotate credentials after migration and use secure parameter stores.
- Skipping dual-run validation:
- Mitigation: run both systems in parallel until parity is proven.
Example migration wave (concrete plan)
- Wave 0: Sandbox — set up TeamCity server, 1 agent, migrate 2 trivial jobs. Validate auth, VCS, artifact storage.
- Wave 1: Utility jobs — linting, static analysis, small unit tests. Run in parallel with Jenkins.
- Wave 2: Feature branch builds — enable branch builds for selected repositories.
- Wave 3: Critical pipelines — release builds, deployment steps, long-running integration tests.
- Wave 4: Decommission — switch webhooks, archive Jenkins data, retire.
Checklist (short)
- Backup Jenkins config and jobs
- Inventory plugins, agents, credentials
- Stand up TeamCity server + agents
- Recreate projects, templates, VCS roots
- Migrate secrets and triggers
- Dual-run validation and compare artifacts
- Cutover, switch webhooks, monitor
- Decommission Jenkins after verification
Migrating from Jenkins to TeamCity requires careful planning, a phased approach, and validation to avoid surprises. With templates, Kotlin DSL, and robust agent management, TeamCity can host reliable, maintainable pipelines that scale with your organization.
Leave a Reply