Detecting a Murmur: Diagnosis, Tests, and Next StepsA heart murmur is an unusual sound heard during the heartbeat cycle — such as a whooshing or swishing — caused by turbulent blood flow in or near the heart. Murmurs can be innocent (harmless) or may indicate an underlying heart problem. This article explains how murmurs are detected, the diagnostic pathway and tests commonly used, how results are interpreted, and the typical next steps for management and follow-up.
What is a heart murmur?
A heart murmur is an extra sound produced when blood flows turbulently through the heart’s chambers or valves. Murmurs vary by:
- Timing in the cardiac cycle: systolic, diastolic, or continuous.
- Intensity (graded I to VI).
- Pitch and quality (soft, harsh, musical, blowing).
- Location where it’s heard best on the chest.
- Whether it changes with maneuvers (e.g., standing, Valsalva).
Some murmurs are “innocent” (also called functional or physiologic): they occur without structural heart disease and are common in infants, children, pregnant people, and athletes. Pathologic murmurs often reflect valve abnormalities (stenosis or regurgitation), congenital heart defects, or conditions that change blood flow (anemia, fever, hyperthyroidism).
How murmurs are first detected
- Clinical history: Symptoms that raise concern include chest pain, shortness of breath, syncope (fainting), palpitations, fatigue, poor growth in infants, or exercise intolerance. A history of rheumatic fever, congenital heart disease, endocarditis, or prior valve disease increases suspicion for a pathologic murmur.
- Physical examination: The primary tool for detection is auscultation with a stethoscope. The clinician documents murmur timing, grade, pitch, location, and radiation (e.g., to the carotids). They also assess for associated findings such as cyanosis, clubbing, peripheral edema, jugular venous distention, or abnormal heart sounds (S3, S4).
Red flags that make a murmur more likely to be pathologic:
- Diastolic murmur.
- Loud (grade ≥ ⁄6) or harsh murmur.
- Murmur with symptoms (syncope, chest pain, dyspnea).
- New murmur in an adult.
- Failure to thrive or abnormal oxygen saturation in infants.
Initial diagnostic tests
If the clinician suspects a pathologic murmur or needs clarification, they typically order tests to evaluate heart structure and function.
- Chest X-ray
- Why: Provides a quick view of heart size and pulmonary vasculature; can identify cardiomegaly or pulmonary edema suggestive of heart failure.
- Limitations: Does not visualize valves directly.
- Electrocardiogram (ECG)
- Why: Detects arrhythmias, chamber enlargement, ischemia, or conduction abnormalities that often accompany structural disease.
- Limitations: Normal ECG does not rule out valvular disease.
- Transthoracic echocardiography (TTE)
- Why: The primary diagnostic tool for evaluating murmurs. Echocardiography uses ultrasound to visualize heart chambers, valve anatomy, chamber sizes, wall motion, and blood flow (via Doppler). It can quantify valve stenosis or regurgitation and estimate pressures.
- Strengths: Noninvasive, widely available, highly informative.
- When: Indicated for most suspected pathologic murmurs, new murmurs in adults, symptomatic patients, or abnormal ECG/CXR.
- Limitations: Image quality can be affected by body habitus or lung disease; sometimes transesophageal echo is needed.
- Transesophageal echocardiography (TEE)
- Why: Provides higher-resolution images of valves and posterior structures; useful when TTE images are suboptimal or when more detail is needed (e.g., suspected endocarditis, prosthetic valve assessment, atrial appendage evaluation).
- Procedure: A probe is passed into the esophagus under sedation.
- Stress testing (exercise ECG, stress echocardiography)
- Why: Assesses symptoms or ischemia provoked by exertion, and can reveal hemodynamically significant valve disease that’s symptomatic only on exertion.
- When: Considered for exertional symptoms with murmurs or to evaluate functional capacity before treatment decisions.
- Cardiac MRI/CT
- Why: Provides detailed anatomic and functional information when echo results are inconclusive or when congenital heart disease or complex pathology is suspected. CT angiography evaluates coronary anatomy if ischemia is a concern.
- Limitations: Higher cost, availability considerations, and contrast/radiation for CT.
- Cardiac catheterization (invasive hemodynamic assessment)
- Why: Directly measures pressures, gradients across valves, and coronary anatomy; used when noninvasive tests are inconclusive or before surgical/interventional procedures.
- When: Indicated for severe valve disease planning (e.g., aortic stenosis with discordant noninvasive results), suspected coronary disease, or when percutaneous valve intervention is under consideration.
- Laboratory tests
- Why: Assess contributing conditions such as anemia, infection, thyroid disease, or markers of heart failure (BNP). Blood cultures are essential if infective endocarditis is suspected.
Interpreting results: innocent vs. pathologic
- Innocent murmurs: Echocardiography is typically normal; no structural or functional abnormality. These murmurs often change with body position and are softer (lower grade).
- Pathologic murmurs: Echo reveals anatomical or functional abnormalities (valvular stenosis/regurgitation, septal defects, cardiomyopathy). Associated symptoms, abnormal ECG/CXR, or elevated biomarkers support a pathologic cause.
Severity assessment (common for valve disease):
- Aortic stenosis: valve area, mean gradient, symptoms, and left ventricular function determine severity and timing of intervention.
- Regurgitant lesions: Regurgitant volume, effective regurgitant orifice area, chamber dilation, and symptom status guide management.
Management and next steps
Management depends on the cause and severity.
- Reassurance and observation
- For innocent murmurs or mild, asymptomatic valve disease: periodic clinical follow-up and repeat echocardiography at intervals determined by the clinician.
- Medical therapy
- For heart failure symptoms, arrhythmias, or to manage contributing conditions:
- Diuretics, ACE inhibitors/ARBs, beta-blockers, mineralocorticoid receptor antagonists for heart failure.
- Anticoagulation for atrial fibrillation when indicated.
- Treat anemia, thyroid disease, or infection as appropriate.
- Interventional or surgical treatment
- Valve repair or replacement: Indicated for severe symptomatic stenosis or regurgitation, or for asymptomatic severe disease with evidence of ventricular dysfunction or adverse remodeling.
- Percutaneous interventions: Balloon valvuloplasty for certain stenotic lesions; transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) for suitable aortic stenosis patients; transcatheter mitral interventions in select cases.
- Closure devices or surgical repair for septal defects or patent ductus arteriosus when clinically indicated.
- Infective endocarditis management
- If endocarditis is suspected: obtain multiple blood cultures, start empiric IV antibiotics based on clinical scenario, involve infectious diseases and cardiothoracic surgery early when complications occur.
- Lifestyle and preventive measures
- Vaccinations (influenza, pneumococcal) for patients with significant heart disease.
- Endocarditis prophylaxis is limited to specific high-risk patients undergoing certain dental or invasive procedures — follow current guidelines.
- Regular follow-up and prompt evaluation for new or worsening symptoms.
Follow-up and monitoring
- Frequency of follow-up depends on diagnosis and severity: innocent murmurs may need no regular echo; mild valve disease often uses echocardiography every 1–3 years; moderate-severe disease requires closer surveillance (every 6–12 months or sooner).
- Patients with prosthetic valves or prior endocarditis need lifelong follow-up and specialized care.
- Clear action plans for when to seek urgent care: new syncope, worsening dyspnea, chest pain, sudden palpitations, or signs of heart failure.
Special populations
- Children: Many murmurs are innocent; however, congenital defects can present as murmurs — pediatric cardiology referral and echocardiography are common when murmurs are persistent, loud, or associated with growth/saturation issues.
- Pregnant people: Increased blood volume can cause functional murmurs; however, murmurs with symptoms or concerning features warrant evaluation because pregnancy stresses cardiac function.
- Elderly: New murmurs are more likely to be pathologic (degenerative valve disease) and frequently need echocardiographic assessment.
Practical patient advice (concise)
- If you hear or are told you have a murmur: get a clinical evaluation.
- Report symptoms: shortness of breath, fainting, chest pain, decreased exercise tolerance.
- Ask whether an echocardiogram is recommended and understand the follow-up interval.
- Maintain heart-healthy habits and manage contributory conditions (blood pressure, lipids, diabetes, anemia).
Summary
A murmur is a sign, not a diagnosis. Detection begins at the bedside with history and auscultation; targeted testing—most importantly transthoracic echocardiography—distinguishes innocent from pathologic murmurs. Management ranges from reassurance and observation to medical therapy, percutaneous procedures, or surgery depending on the underlying cause and severity. Timely evaluation ensures appropriate monitoring and treatment to prevent complications.
Leave a Reply